Picked this up after my stellar experience with the unlined version. I'm 5'7", about 165 lbs. with broad shoulders (40R in a suit jacket) and ordered a M like my previous jacket. It was too restrictive for another layer outside of a thin sweater, so I sized up to a Large. Thankfully, the sleeves cuff very well for my short arms. I was pleasantly surprised how it blocks wind given the deceptively light lining. Doesn't have handwarmer pockets on the side, which may be a bigger deal for you in a late fall/winter jacket, but I personally don't mind. It's refreshing to wear on the streets of NYC among a sea of puffer jackets (just fine in the high 30s/low 40s F with a hoodie, your mileage may vary).